HIIT vs Steady State Cardio: Which One Is Better?

When people think of cardio, they tend to picture somebody jogging around the block, or somebody stuck in the gym, sweating on a treadmill for 45-60 minutes. For years, that kind of constant, steady cardio was thought to be the most effective way to melt those pounds away. But with the growing popularity of high-intensity interval training (HIIT), more and more people are wondering which one is actually better.

The truth is that everybody is different, and everybody responds differently to various methods of training. In this article we’ll compare HIIT and steady state cardio head-to-head – what each one is, their pros and cons, what the research says about fat loss, fitness and time – and help you decide which one is right for you.

What Is HIIT?

HIIT is a method of cardio training in which you alternate short periods of very hard effort with periods of easy, active recovery. A typical HIIT workout might look like walking or jogging slowly for 90 seconds, then sprinting as hard as you can for around 30 seconds, and repeating that 8-12 times. The hard intervals can last anywhere from 8 seconds to 4 minutes, depending on the workout.

HIIT can be done on cardio machines, outdoors, with bodyweight exercises, or even in the swimming pool. Here are the main HIIT benefits in more detail.

What Is Steady State Cardio?

Steady state cardio, sometimes called steady pace or moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT), is just as the name implies: cardio performed at a steady, continuous pace for a prolonged period of time – usually anything from 20 to 90 minutes. Brisk walking, jogging, cycling, swimming or most of the people you see on the treadmill at a steady pace are doing this form of exercise. You should be working hard enough to breathe faster, but still able to hold a conversation.

HIIT vs Steady State Cardio: What the Research Says

Time Efficiency: HIIT Wins

The great thing about HIIT is that it’s quick – a typical HIIT workout lasts less than 30 minutes, including the warm-up and cool-down. And research shows that you can get similar results in a fraction of the time.

In a study from McMaster University, one group did short, all-out sprint intervals while another did 90-120 minutes of steady cycling. After two weeks, both groups improved their fitness and muscle endurance by the same amount – but the sprint group trained for only about 2.5 hours in total, compared with 10.5 hours for the steady cardio group.

Fitness: HIIT Has a Slight Edge

Both types of cardio make your heart and lungs stronger. But a meta-analysis of 28 studies found that HIIT improved VO2max – the best measure of aerobic fitness – slightly more than steady endurance training. And because HIIT also trains your anaerobic system, it carries over better to sports that involve sprinting, jumping and changes of pace.

Fat Loss: Roughly a Tie – But HIIT Takes Less Time

This is where most people want an answer, so let’s be honest: when it comes to fat loss, both work. A review of 13 studies in overweight and obese adults found that HIIT and steady state cardio reduced body fat by a similar amount – but HIIT took about 40% less training time.

Some individual studies have found an advantage for HIIT. In a well-known 2008 study published in the International Journal of Obesity, young women did either 20 minutes of HIIT (8-second sprints followed by 12 seconds of easy pedaling on a bike) or 40 minutes of steady cycling, three times a week for 15 weeks. Only the HIIT group lost a significant amount of body fat – including fat from the trunk – and improved their insulin levels.

What about the “afterburn” effect? It’s true that after a hard workout your body keeps burning extra calories while it recovers – this is called excess post-exercise oxygen consumption (EPOC). But a review of the research found that it adds only about 6-15% on top of the calories you burned during the workout. So most of the difference comes from the workout itself – and from your diet.

Appetite: A Small Win for HIIT

Some people claim that HIIT also helps them lose weight by suppressing their appetite – and there’s some research to back it up. In a study of overweight, inactive men, those who did high-intensity intervals ate less at their next meal than after resting or after steady cardio. That improves your chances of not overcompensating for all the calories you burned in your workout. It’s not a huge effect, but every bit helps.

Enjoyment: It Depends on You

You might think nobody could enjoy something as brutal as HIIT. But in a 2011 study, recreationally active men actually rated interval running as more enjoyable than 50 minutes of steady running – even though it felt harder. The workouts are short, they fly by, and there’s always variety. On the other hand, plenty of people dread the intensity and prefer the relaxed rhythm of a long walk or jog. And that matters, because the best cardio is the one you’ll actually stick with.

HIIT: Pros and Cons

Pros

  • It can be done quickly. 15-25 minutes is enough, which makes it great for people who aren’t blessed with a lot of time.
  • You burn a lot of calories in less time. It doesn’t matter how long you spend in the gym – what matters is what you do in that time.
  • You need no equipment. You can use bikes and treadmills, but if you don’t have access to a gym, simply find an open space – a field, perhaps – and away you go.
  • It never gets boring. You can change the exercises, the length of the intervals and the rest periods, so you keep challenging your body.

Cons

  • It’s hard. Make no mistake – just because the workout is over quickly doesn’t mean it’s easy. HIIT is physically draining, and each round gets harder than the last.
  • It needs more recovery. You shouldn’t do HIIT more than 2-3 times a week. If you do sessions more frequently, your body won’t have time to recover and you won’t be able to keep up with the intensity.
  • It’s tougher on your joints. All-out sprints and jumps put more stress on your knees, hips and ankles – especially if you’re overweight or new to training.
  • It’s not ideal for complete beginners. If you’re new to exercise, build a base with steady cardio first, then ease into HIIT with low-impact options like the bike or rower.

Steady State Cardio: Pros and Cons

Pros

  • You recover faster. Steady cardio is far less grueling on your body, so it won’t interfere much with your weight training – you can even do it on rest days.
  • It’s easier on your joints, especially low-impact options like cycling, swimming or incline walking.
  • It’s beginner-friendly. Anyone can start with a brisk walk.
  • It builds your aerobic base, which is essential for endurance sports like running or cycling.
  • It’s relaxing. For many people, a long walk or bike ride is a great way to clear their head and lower stress.

Cons

  • It takes a long time. You need about twice as much time to get similar results as with HIIT.
  • It can get boring, and if you always do the same cardio at the same intensity, your body gets used to it.
  • You need patience before you see noticeable results in your physique and fitness.

So, Which One Is Better?

The honest answer: neither one is better for everyone. Both improve your fitness, your heart health and your body composition. The main difference is time:

  • Choose HIIT if you’re short on time, you’re already reasonably fit, and you enjoy pushing yourself.
  • Choose steady state cardio if you’re a beginner, you have joint problems, you’re training for an endurance event, or you need cardio that won’t interfere with heavy leg training.
  • Or better yet, do both. For most people, the best approach is 1-2 HIIT sessions a week plus 1-3 sessions of steady cardio – like a long walk or an easy bike ride on your rest days.

And remember that for fat loss, no type of cardio can beat a bad diet. Get your nutrition right first, and then use cardio to speed things up.

If you have any health condition, high blood pressure or a heart problem, or you’re prone to injuries, consult with your doctor about which type of exercise is best for you before starting HIIT.

Conclusion

In the battle between HIIT and steady state cardio, there’s no knockout winner. HIIT gives you similar – and sometimes slightly better – results in about half the time, while steady cardio is easier to recover from, gentler on your joints and great for beginners. Pick the one you enjoy and can stick with, or combine the two for the best of both worlds. Want to try HIIT? Here are 5 great home HIIT workouts to get you started.

Related:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *